Download e-book for kindle: A Commentary on Thucydides: Volume II: Books IV-V. 24 by Simon Hornblower

By Simon Hornblower

ISBN-10: 019814881X

ISBN-13: 9780198148814

This can be the second one quantity of a three-volume ancient and literary remark of the 8 books of Thucydides, the good fifth-century BC historian of the Peloponnesian warfare among Athens and Sparta. Books iv-v.24 disguise the years 425-421 BC and comprise the Pylos-Spakteria narrative, the Delion crusade, and Brasidas' operations within the north of Greece. This quantity ends with the Peace of Nikias and the alliance among Athens and Sparta. a brand new characteristic of this quantity is the whole thematic advent which discusses such subject matters as Thucydides and Herodotus, Thucydide's presentation of Brasidas, Thucydides and kinship, speech--direct and indirect--in iv-v.24, Thucydides and epigraphy (including own names), iv-v.24 as a piece of paintings: cutting edge or basically incomplete? Thucydides meant his paintings to be "an eternal ownership" and the continued value of his paintings is undisputed. Simon Hornblower's remark, by means of translating each passage of Greek commented on for the 1st time, permits readers with very little Greek to understand the element of Thucydides' notion and subject-matter. a whole index on the finish of the quantity.

Show description

Read or Download A Commentary on Thucydides: Volume II: Books IV-V. 24 PDF

Best medieval books

Download e-book for iPad: Chaucer and the Tradition of the Roman Antique by Barbara Nolan

It is a exact research of Chaucer's poetics in Troilus and Criseyde and the Knight's story relating to a tremendous continental narrative culture. it's the first such wide-ranging learn on the grounds that Charles Muscatine's seminal Chaucer and the French culture and the 1st ebook to argue intimately that Chaucer's poems, Boccaccio's Filostrato and Teseida and the twelfth-century French romans antiques perform a unique formal culture in the protean box of medieval romance.

Simon Hornblower's Thucydides and Pindar: Historical Narrative and the World of PDF

Simon Hornblower argues for a dating among Thucydides and Pindar no longer to date stated in glossy scholarship. He argues that old critics have been correct to realize stylistic similarities among those nice exponents of the "severe kind" in prose and verse. partly One he explores the heritage of epinikian poetry and athletics, the values shared via the 2 authors, and faith and colonization myths, and offers a geographically geared up survey of Pindar's Mediterranean global, exploiting onomastic proof.

Altnordische Philologie. Norwegen und Island by Odd Einar Haugen; Aus dem Norwegischen von Astrid van Nahl PDF

Das Handbuch bietet einen breiten Überblick über altnorwegische und altisländische Sprache und Literatur mit den Bereichen Handschriftenkunde, Textkritik, Runologie, Paläographie, Namen, Sprachgeschichte vom Altnordischen bis zum Mittelnorwegischen, Saga, Edda und Skaldik. Eine Fülle von Illustrationen und Faksimiles erleichtertden Einstieg in die einzelnen Themenbereiche; viele von ihnen sind zu weiterführenden Studien in Farbe auf einer eigens eingerichteten Homepage zu finden.

Extra resources for A Commentary on Thucydides: Volume II: Books IV-V. 24

Example text

59. Stroud (above, n. 61), 302. 41 4 1 4 1 4 1 21 Introduction so obvious. It seems to me that visits to Corinth (and Sparta—and Argos—and Mantinea—and so on) would answer as well: exiles regularly moved around a good deal. But Stroud is particularly concerned to demolish what he calls the 'tale* that Thucydides spent his exile in Thrace, writing his history under a plane-tree, a tale handed down by Marcellinus and Plutarch. Stroud misrepresents my own views on this point, in two distinct respects.

To admit the similarity but say there is no need to posit a debt. If the parallel is more lengthy and complex, the move will be to point up the discrepancies, and there will be some, and to say 'look at these discrepancies, they show Thucydides wasn't following Herodotus faithfully, therefore he wasn't following him or criticizing him at all'. As to the first strategy, I myself in 1992 listed a number of passages which though offering parallels did not, I argued, require us to suppose Herodotus was in Thucydides' mind; 1 added that sometimes other people such as Hellanicus may have been the objects of his remarks.

78. Thucydides and Herodotus p. 131, for the non-Herodotean Theban claim that their government in 427 was different in type from the medizing government of 480—an obvious rhetorical ploy. Finally, Kennelly notes that Thucydides did not get from Herodotus the statement that Plataia fell in the 93rd year after its alliance with Athens. Indeed he did not, but that statement is not part of the speech, it is in the narrative But all this is to operate in far too narrow a framework of argument. My 1992 challenge was and is to find past events mentioned in Thucydidean speeches which are wholly unknown to us from the Herodotean tradition.

Download PDF sample

A Commentary on Thucydides: Volume II: Books IV-V. 24 by Simon Hornblower


by Kevin
4.1

Rated 4.88 of 5 – based on 49 votes